Demonstration against the Taipei Dome

The Taipei Dome (大巨蛋, „big giant egg“), located next to Songshan Culture Park, is one of those „development“ projects that currently abound in Taipei. A 40.000-seat-indoor baseball stadium right across from Sun Yat Sen Memorial Hall, a shopping mall, hotels and office buildings. Business as usual. Big corporations pour lots of concrete and make a lot of money. Citizens and tourists go shopping.

So what is the problem with it?

The problem, as many people see it, is that by greenlighting the construction of the Taipei Dome, the Taipei City government has thrown away the chance to establish something the city and its people really need – namely, a second inner-city forest park.

That is why there is a protest movement. Recently a few hundred people held a protest march (video) from Taipei City Hall to the headquarters of the developer, Farglory Group, and on the the site where the concrete has already started pouring. (newspaper report)

I admire all these citizen groups in Taiwan hitting the streets to protest for their cause. They are too late this time, I am afraid. Big business has succeeded again in establishing facts (chopping down trees, bringing in the big machines, digging holes) before public pressure could make politicians change their minds.

Demonstration Taipei Dome

Citizens protesting against the loss of urban green spaces, 30 Oct 2011.

What a great park this could have been. No one would deny that is was a stroke of genius to establish Daan Forest Park, a few kilometers away to the south-west, at the site of a former military village. But it is just one site. Another forest park, not quite as big, directly across from Sun Yat Sen Memorial Hall would really have breathed life into this part of the city. There are not a lot of green spaces left in the East District along Zhongxiao East Rd.

But there used to be this magnificent spot that is the former Songshan Tobacco Factory. After closing down (apparently in 1998), its grounds had been neglected for years. Trees could grow, wildlife could spread. This is how it looked like (source):

Songshan Tobacco Factory 2006

Before: The area in 2006.

But around 2005/2006, the Taipei City Government signed a contract to turn the area over to Farglory and have them build the „Taipei Arena“ there. As a BOT (build-operate-transfer) project, Farglory would operate the project for 50 years (sacking in all the profits) and then return the area (including a by then probably derelict building) to the city.

Enviromentalists and people from the area (there is a primary school next door) protested and sued. But before all rulings were final, or the project had passed all enviromental impact assessments, the City Government already started removing trees.

“It’s perfectly legal that we act according to the results of the first assessment before the second [environmental impact] assessment is complete,” said Lee Kan (李侃), executive secretary of the Taipei Cultural and Sports Park — the official name of the future dome complex. “So far, we haven’t received any court order asking us to stop the construction.”
Green Party Taiwan halts tree removal at site of old Songshan Tobacco Factory

Green Party protest tree removal

Calvin Wen of the Green Party Taiwan tries to prevent a camphor tree tree from being cut down, 27 Feb 2009.

(Source)

After a few hundred trees had been cut down, the area – carefully hidden from public view by high fences – looked like this (source):

Songshan Taipei Dome site 2009

After: The area in 2009.

More than two years later, Taipei City’s Environmental Impact Assessment Review Committee, voting eight to five, approved the construction. The officials demanded some minor changes (like less floor space but more parking) to make it look like they actually were interested in changing anything.

Taipei Dome gets a green light

So now the big machines could start rolling in. This is what the site looks like now, looking south from the old factory building towards SYS Memorial Hall. Mind you, this could have been your Forest Park.

Songshan Tobacco Factory 2011 construction site

Too late: The area now.

Sure, the actual Songshan Tobacco Factory Building is still there, as are some trees surrounding it and even a pond. It is a great location which the Design Expo just made good use of. But it occupies just part of the total area.
Taipei Dome site

After the construction has finished, this really nice spot will be squeezed in between the Taipei Dome, shopping malls etc. to the south and west, and a new high-rise hotel to the north. Instead of a park with a clear view all the way down to SYS Memorial Hall.

Try to find a nice spot to lie down on the lawn and enjoy the sunshine here:
Taipei Dome plan
(Source: Official Farglory Dome website)

Because huge corporations often take citizens to be complete idiots, they are even promoting this huge building made of concrete, for which hundreds of trees have been cut down, with the slogan „Enviromental Protection“.

Taipei Dome construction site fence

„Enviromental Protection“?! Sure…

The protesters beg to differ.

Taipei Dome demonstration banner

Untranslatable pun. Roughly means „Taipei Dome, p*ss off!“

I am pretty sure it is too late to stop the construction of the Taipei Dome. I think the best the protesters can do is make the Taipei City Government aware that it cannot go on turning those few precious open spaces that are left in the inner city over to developers. Because cities are primarily for people to live in, not for corporations to make money at everyone’s expense.

Next could be the greenland behind Huashan 1914 Culture Park, stretching south of Citizen Boulevard and westward to Linsen Rd. After the railroad tracks were moved underground, this huge area became „available“. The central government has already decided to build a „Service Center“ at the western end, where there is currently an art installation. I am pretty sure those are not the only plans.

Read more English Taiwan posts on this otherwise mostly German blog.

Other posts you might want to have a look at:

Interesting? Using Flattr, you can support content you like by donating a few cents.

Share on Facebook148Share on Google+1Tweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someone

14 Kommentare zu “ Taipei Dome protests: How citizens don’t get a second forest park, but just another shopping mall ”

  1. I’m kinda split on this one. Taipei definitely needs more parks, that’s for sure, but we also need more shopping and business centers. It’s just so crowded everywhere you go, especially in the Main Station area and around City Hall and it would help to direct the crowds to some other parts of the city as well. I don’t see this small piece of land fixing the problem of green spaces in Taipei, but it speaks volumes about how big the problem is, if people feel the urge to protest (and I completely support their freedom of doing so). I don’t know of any real solutions for both problems. Overpopulation, a severe centralization and an insufficient infrastructure are causing Taipei’s problems of today in regards to both issues. If more political and economic power would be given to other parts of Taiwan and if infrastructure would be improved, we might get hope that Taipeiers can enjoy a better quality of life. But what can you do, if Taipei is the only city in Taiwan where you can earn a decent buck? Everybody wants to live and work here (including me). If me and my wife got the same pay in Kaohsiung, we’d be there in no time.

    • Klaus sagt:

      > „Taipei (needs) more shopping and business centers“
      Respectfully, I disagree in every possible way. What people in Taipei need is to get their priorities straight.
      Also, I do not see that as a „small“ piece of land. It is almost as big as Daan Park.

      I understand the attraction Kaohsiung has towards Taipei dwellers. Keep in mind, with the rents and cost of living there, you do not even need to earn as much as in Taipei.

      • Alex sagt:

        Klaus, your view is a German one. Taiwanese people like to „sanbu“ in a department store, so a German park would be a Taiwanese shopping mall. So there is definitely a need for another shopping area.

      • Klaus sagt:

        Well, I did not see many other Germans during that demonstration.

  2. Alex sagt:

    To add, even Da’an park is partly a shopping area… 😉

  3. richard sagt:

    my Polish point of view supports the German point of view for a better wellbeing of all of us in Taipei

  4. I have had fears for the Culture Park before – the area is vast, and while sometimes a very noisy spot (the Shimin elevated highway!) it provides Europeans with a sense of history – old leftover tracks are still there somewhere to be discovered, you can see the reasons for moving them underground from the map. The old factories in the Eastern bit have a sense of tranquility left which I enjoy every time. But maybe thats just me.

    And yes, I’d hate to see my hairdresser in Beiping Donglu go bankrupt if overshadowed by a nearby shopping mall. 🙁

  5. alex sagt:

    Another Shopping mall, great.. no seriously even my Girlfriend said there is no need for more shopping malls and she is a shopping addict. By the way the shopping malls only consist of expensive Armani Stores and Sogo etc, could they at least make a decent shopping mall where people actually can spend some money? We don’t have that problem here in Taichung, it’s kinda boring here, not so much shopping 😉

  6. Ruby sagt:

    „Taiwanese people like to “sanbu” in a department store, so a German park would be a Taiwanese shopping mall“

    I totally disagree with this opinion.
    I’m a Taiwanese and I love „Green“ as well.

    • Alex H. sagt:

      Ok, it seems you are a minority. For Taiwanese, It’s just nicer to walk in a dry space like a shopping mall than in a often rainy park. And for most people it’s just about looking, not buying. Most people go anyway into the food court which seems the most important area. Which park has a dry food court??

  7. alex sagt:

    „I totally disagree with this opinion.
    I’m a Taiwanese and I love “Green” as well.“

    put most Taiwanese prefer shopping and look strange when they see someone sitting on the grass (his cloths must be dirth!!). And just a few people really enjoy nature, the most people won’t even leave their tour bus to get some fresh air only if it’s „sakula“ – a hundred photos and back in the bus 😉

  8. Hans sagt:

    Oh Mann, wer baut den heute noch ein Stadion mitten im Stadtzentrum. Viel Spass beim parken.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks:

  1. […] Pretty much everything that could go wrong has—often more than once. It has been the site of countless protests over the many years since plans were announced to redevelop the site of the old Songshan Tobacco Factory into a […]

Kommentar abgeben